![]() ![]() Next at 4:03, two torpedoes are shown hitting a JH attack ship and the big battlcruiser commandship. Which is 50 percent above your stated range of 10 percent. Two out of three possible hits is 60 percent accuracy. To be fair, we'll assume that the Galor was the sole target of the attack. Deep Space Nine returns fire with three torpedoes shown flying off, one goes past a Cardassian Galor and two slam into it. Starting at 3:53 all hits from the Dominion fleet hit the station for 100 percent accuracy. Oh just to head off the troll, here is the battle from "A Call to Arms". And the deflector has been used to push a nearly Moon-sized asteroid in "The Paradise Syndrome". Not to mention you can cite every time the E-D goes to warp and her navigational deflectors keep her hull from having huge holes punched through her as well. ![]() The E-D deflects a shuttle attempting to ram it in "The Hunted" while in a prior episode, "Datalore", the E-D deflects the kilometers-sized Crystalline Entity with ease when it tries to attack the ship. With shields up we have often seen Federation ships and other contemporary vessels deflect objects. When the Bozeman struck her, it was to the starboard warp nacelle and that alone did not destroy the ship. Furthermore, in "Cause and Effect", the E-D was motionless, could not raise shields or had navigational deflectors due to a strange space anomaly. Odyssey, and Odyssey survived for several seconds afterwords, even with a huge chunk of her lower stardrive section blown away. Basically it's been concluded that the attack ship detonated it's warp core on contact with the U.S.S. Also look up the Jem'Hadar ramming incident here on SFJN. Just look at ST-vs-SW.Net and look at the kinetic energy essay page. Nor have you proven that the enterprise can survive a strike from the MAC, when we see many times in TNG and DS9 that federation ships shields and armour can not stop such impacts.”Īnd the actual link is here. “The torpedoes may have the kick to do as you suggest, but you haven’t proven they could actually hit because in the series they miss a good 90% of the time against ships sluggishly moving around, movements that UNSC ships exceed. A 600 ton projectile doing an appreciable fraction of c is going to utterly rape the E-D.” Every time, Every single time in the series that a federation ship has been hit by anything, even grazed by another ship, they take horrific damage or even blow up. “Federation ships can not take collisions, even with their shields up. It’s always been pretty obvious in my mind that the E-D is superior, but if you could confirm whether or not his arguments are valid or complete lies, that would be helpful. So I’ve been having an argument with a member on another website, Cananatra, on the topic of the Pillar of Autumn vs the Enterprise-D. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |